Eclecticism in architecture  

From The Art and Popular Culture Encyclopedia

Antwerpen-Centraal railway station, see Eclectic architecture in Belgium

Related e

Wikipedia Wiktionary Shop Featured: Rhombicuboctahedron by Leonardo da Vinci

Eclecticism is a 19th and 20th century architectural style in which a single piece of work incorporates a mixture of elements from previous historical styles to create something that is new and original. In architecture and interior design, these elements may include structural features, furniture, decorative motives, distinct historical ornament, traditional cultural motifs or styles from other countries, with the mixture usually chosen based on its suitability to the project and overall aesthetic value.

The term is also used of the many architects of the 19th and early 20th centuries who designed buildings in a variety of styles according to the wishes of their clients, or their own. The styles were typically revivalist, and each building might be mostly or entirely consistent within the style selected, or itself an eclectic mixture. Gothic Revival architecture, especially in churches, was most likely to strive for a relatively "pure" revival style from a particular medieval period and region, while other revived styles such as Neoclassical, Baroque, Palazzo style, Jacobethan, Romanesque and many others were likely to be treated more freely.

History

Eclecticism came into practice during the late 19th century, as architects sought a style that would allow them to retain previous historic precedent, but create unseen designs. From a complete catalogue of past styles, the ability to mix and combine styles allowed for more expressive freedom and provided an endless source of inspiration. Whilst other design professionals (referred to as 'revivalists') aimed to meticulously imitate past styles, Eclecticism differed, as the main driving force was creation, not nostalgia and there was a desire for the designs to be original.

Europe

Eclectic architecture first appeared across continental Europe in various countries such as France (Beaux-Arts architecture), England (Victorian architecture) and Germany (Gründerzeit), in response to the growing push amongst architects to have more expressive freedom over their work.

The École des Beaux-Arts in Paris, considered to be one of the first professional architectural schools, trained students in a rigorous and academic manner, equipping them with skills and professional prestige. Teachers at the École were some of the leading architects in France, and this new method of teaching was so successful, that it attracted students from across the globe. Many of the graduates went on to become pioneers of the movement, and used their Beaux-Arts training as a foundation for new eclectic designs.

Whilst the practise of this style of architecture was widespread (and could be seen in many town halls constructed at the time), eclecticism in Europe did not achieve the same level of enthusiasm that was seen in America – as it was assumed that the presence of old, authentic architecture, reduced the appeal of historical imitation in new buildings.

North America

The end of the 19th century saw a profound shift in American Architecture. Architects educated at the École des Beaux-Arts in Paris, such as Richard Morris Hunt and Charles Follen McKim were responsible for bringing the beaux-arts approach back from Europe, which was said to be the cornerstone of eclectic architecture in America. At a time of increasing prosperity and commercial pride, many eclectic buildings were commissioned in large cities around the country. The style thrived, as it introduced historical features, previously only seen in the aristocratic architecture of European countries such as Britain and France, contributing to a richer sense of culture and history within America. In the case of Hunt and many other eclectic architects, his 'typically eclectic viewpoint' enabled him to make stylistic choices based on whatever suited the particular project or the client. This flexibility to adapt, and to blend freely between styles gave eclectic designers more appeal to clients.

The creation of skyscrapers and other large public spaces such as churches, courthouses, city halls, public libraries and movie theatres, meant that eclectic design was no longer only for members of high-society, but was also accessible to the general public. While some of these buildings have since been demolished (including the original Pennsylvania station and the first Madison Square garden—both in New York City), projects that remain from this era are still valued as some of the most important structures in America.

Spread

Some of the most extreme examples of eclectic design could be seen onboard ocean liners (which at the time were the primary form of overseas transport). The lavish interiors were crafted with a mix of traditional styles—in an attempt to ease the discomfort of months abroad and to create the illusion of established grandeur.

At a similar time, such vessels were being used to transport colonists to undeveloped areas of the world. The colonisation of such areas, further spread the Eclectic architecture of the western world, as newly settled colonists built structures commonly featuring Roman classicism and Gothic motifs.

To a lesser extent, Eclecticism appeared across Asia, as Japanese and Chinese architects who had trained at American Beaux-Arts influenced schools, returned to produce eclectic designs across Asia such as the Bank of Japan (1895) by Kingo Tatsuno. The so-called Indo-Saracenic Revival architecture, which added details from traditional Indian architecture, mostly Mughal architecture, to essentially Western forms of public buildings and palaces, was an inherently eclectic style. Most of the architects were British.

Critical reception

As a style that offered so much creative freedom, and no guiding rules, the risk of creating an unsuccessful design was apparent to all. Projects that failed to harmoniously blend the different styles were subject to criticism from professionals (particularly those who opposed the movement).

Decline

Enthusiasm for historical imitation began to decline in the 1930s and eclecticism was phased out in the curriculums of design schools, in favour of a new style. The shift towards Late Modernism, Postmodernism, Brutalism, Art Deco and Streamline Moderne was significant as it was seen by many as avant-garde and the new technology and materials being produced at the time allowed for greater innovation. Despite the move away from eclecticism, the era still remains historically significant as it "re-opened the doors to innovation and new forms" for architecture in the following years.

Interior design

The rise in eclectic architecture created a need for interior specialists who had the skill, understanding and knowledge of past historical styles, to produce suitable accompanying interiors. This resulted in the emergence of interior designer as a regarded profession. Prominent interior designers in this era (between the late 19th and early 20th century) include Elsie De Wolfe, Rose Cumming, Nancy McClelland, Elsie Cobb Wilson, Francis Elkins, Surie Maugham and Dorothy Draper. Whilst the clientele of these early designers consisted exclusively of wealthy families and businesses, the works of such decorators were regularly featured in popular publications such as House and Garden, House Beautiful, and the Ladies Home Journal. Publishing the lavish interiors of these magnificent homes helped to spread the eclectic style to the middle classes, and less extravagant imitations or the incorporation of similar decorative elements became a desirable feature in domestic decoration. Aesthetic preferences varied from region to region across America, with Spanish styles being favoured in California, and elements of American Colonial architecture being popular in New England.

Contemporary context

In contemporary society, styles that draw from many different cultural and historical styles are loosely described as "eclectic" though references to eclectic architecture within literature and media are usually about buildings constructed within the eclectic movement of the late 19th-early 20th century period.

Eclectic architects

• Daniel Burnham
• Alexander Jackson Davis
• Antonio Gaudi
• Josef Hlávka
• Richard Morris Hunt
• Charles Follen McKim
• William Rutherford Mead
• Richard Norman Shaw
• Stanford White

See also

• Eclecticism
• Eclecticism in art
• Historicism (art)
• Neo-eclectic architecture (McMansions)
• Revivalism (architecture)

Linking in in 2022

20 January 1920 Street, Bydgoszcz, 3 Maja Street, Bydgoszcz, A. M. Detmer House, Aartswoud, Adolf Schill, Albright United Methodist Church, Alella, Alexandru Mocioni Square, Alfred Waterhouse, Al-Hussein Mosque, American Legion Post No. 512, Amzei Church, Angle, Pembrokeshire, Annonay, Anspach Fountain, Antonio Palacios, Antwerp, Apache Powder Historic Residential District, Arad, Romania, Architectural pattern book, Architecture of Baku, Architecture of Estonia, Architecture of Germany, Architecture of Hungary, Architecture of Peru, Architecture of Russia, Architecture of Serbia, Architecture of Uttar Pradesh, Argentina, Argeș County Museum, Armour Theatre Building, Armour–Stiner House, Arseny Morozov House, Art Nouveau in Brussels, Art Nouveau in Madrid, Art Nouveau in Milan, Art Nouveau, Ascension Cathedral, Almaty, August Cieszkowski Street, Bydgoszcz, Augusto Montenegro Mansion, Avenue de Tervueren, Avenue Franklin Roosevelt, Avram Iancu Square, Cluj-Napoca, Babia Wieś Street, Bydgoszcz, Bank of Spain Building (Pontevedra), Basilica and Convent of San Francisco, Quito, Basilica of Our Lady of Nazareth of Exile, Belvedere on the Pfingstberg, Benoordenhout, Bernard Maybeck, Beti Jai fronton, Bishop's Palace, Galveston, Blair Theatre, Blumwes' buildings in Bydgoszcz, Bocianowo Street, Bydgoszcz, Bogdan Raczkowski, Bolesława Chrobrego Street, Bolonha Mansion, Boulevard Adolphe Max, Boulevard Anspach, Brumback Library, Brussels Stock Exchange, Brussels, Bucharest, Bucharev manufactory shop, Buildings and architecture of Bristol, Burdaard, Bydgoszcz Architects (1850–1970s), Café Moderno (Pontevedra), Capilla del Carmen (Valparaíso), Carey House (Wichita, Kansas), Carl Meyer Tenement, Carl Peschel Tenement, Carl Peschel Tenement, Carl Rose Tenement, Carmel Woods, Carrick Borough Building, Cartouche (design), Caryatid Building, Casa Bonet (Barcelona), Casa de los Dragones, Casa del Rey Apartments, Casa Grande Hotel (Elk City, Oklahoma), Casa Mulleras, Casa Rosada, Castro Urdiales, Cathedral of the Intercession (Shakhty), Caux Palace Hotel, Central Boulevards of Brussels, Cetate Synagogue, Charles Frederick Myers house, Charles LeFeber House, Chelyabinsk, Chirikov House, Chocimska Street, Bydgoszcz, Church of Saint Peter Gonzalez, Church of Saints Peter and Paul in Razhanka, Church of St Peter, Frankfurt, Church of St. Catherine of Genoa (Manhattan), Church of St. Clare, Horodkivka, Church of the Assumption, Nedvigovka, Church of the Immaculate Conception (Cooks Creek, Manitoba), Church of the Intercession (Konstantinovsk), Church of the Intercession (Novocherkassk), City of Brussels, Classical architecture, Clock Tower (Iquique), Clock Tower, Herne Bay, Clyde Carter House, Cobble Hill Farm, College Hill Town Hall, Colombia, Colón, Cuba, Contemporary Architecture (journal), Corbel, Corinthia Grand Hotel Astoria, Covering of the Senne, Czarnków, D. Mendeleev University of Chemical Technology of Russia, Daily News Building, Daneliuska huset, David Eccles House, Desyatinny Monastery, Deva House, Dipolog Cathedral, Długa Street, Bydgoszcz, Doktora Emila Warmińskiego street in Bydgoszcz, Door, Dragutin Djordjević, Dworcowa Street, Dworcowa Street, edit) Eclectic, Eclecticism, Eden Park Station No. 7, Edgerton (neighborhood), Edificio Armada de Chile, Edificio Castromil, Edificio Grassy, Edificio London París, Edo Šen, Edwards County Courthouse and Jail, Edwin Smith House (Wellington, Kansas), Eger Synagogue, El Paseo Building, Eleftherias Square, Elisabetin Roman Catholic Church, Elizabeth C. Quinlan House, Embassy of Germany, Saint Petersburg, Embassy of the Philippines, The Hague, Emil Bernhardt Tenement, Emmanuel Episcopal Church (San Angelo, Texas), Erik Josephson, Escandón, F. N. Solodov House, Fabric Synagogue, Faculty of Fine Arts of Pontevedra, Fairfield District School, Farna Street, Bydgoszcz, Father Stanisław Konarski Street, Bydgoszcz, First Presbyterian Church (San Angelo, Texas), Fonseca House, Forest Heights, Knoxville, Fountain House (Saint Petersburg), Frank Freeman (architect), Frederick W. Winters House, Freedom Square 1, Bydgoszcz, Freetown-Port Rico Historic District, Fringe Club, Fritz Weidner, Fundación Carlos de Amberes, Galveston Orphans Home, Garbary Street, Gdańsk Street 22, Bydgoszcz, Gdańsk Street 33, Bydgoszcz, Gdańsk Street 71, Bydgoszcz, Gdańsk Street 75, Bydgoszcz, Gdańsk Street 86, Bydgoszcz, Gdańsk Street 91, Bydgoszcz, Gdańsk Street, Bydgoszcz, Gdańsk Street, Bydgoszcz, Gent-Sint-Pieters railway station, George Hummel House, George Pick House, Germania Club Building, Gimnazjalna, Libelta and Szwalbego Streets, Bydgoszcz, Goldsboro Union Station, Governor's Palace, Vatican, Grigore Sturdza, Grodzka Street, Bydgoszcz, Grunwaldzka Street, Bydgoszcz, Guadalajara, Guanabara Palace, Gustavo R. Vincenti, Guzmán Family Pantheon, Halifax City Hall, Hamilton Army Airfield, Hankar House, Harris House (Little Rock, Arkansas), Harris House (Little Rock, Arkansas), Harrison Memorial Library, Harry F. Sinclair House, Hawaii Theatre, Headquarters of the Provincial Bank of Córdoba, Helen Shedd Reed House, Helmer-Winnett-White Flats, Henryka Sienkiewicza Street, High School No. 6, Bydgoszcz, Higher School for the Conservation and Restoration of Cultural Property in Galicia, History of architecture, History of art, Holy Rosary Church (Rochester, New York), Hospital of Maudes, Hotel Métropole, Brussels, Hotel Nacional de Cuba, Humboldt Park (Chicago park), I.I. Karzinkin House, Iglesia de San Agustín (La Serena), Iglesia de San Agustín (La Serena), Iglesia de San Antonio de Padua, Illa de la Discòrdia, Index of architecture articles, Indo-Saracenic architecture, Institut d'Art et d'Archéologie, Institutes of Agriculture, Bydgoszcz, Iosefin Synagogue, Isa bek Hajinski House, Isabelline (architectural style), Israelite High School (Timișoara), Iuliu Maniu Street, Cluj-Napoca, Jagiellońska Street, Bydgoszcz, Jan and Jędrzej Śniadecki Street, Bydgoszcz, Jana Karola Chodkiewicza Street, Bydgoszcz, Jana Zamoyskiego Street, Bydgoszcz, Janja Mihailović, Japanese-Western Eclectic Architecture, Jezuicka Street, Bydgoszcz, João Goulart's House, Johan Jacob Ahrenberg, John Green Mausoleum, John Hamrick, John R. Brinkley, Józef Święcicki Tenement, Józef Święcicki, Józef Weyssenhoff Square, Bydgoszcz, Julius Grey House, Juliusz Heinzl Palace, Juliusz Słowacki Theatre, Jumilla, Jumurda Manor, Károlyi Castle, Fehérvárcsurgó, Kartamyshevska Street, Kłanino Palace, Kocher Building, Kołłątaja Street, Bydgoszcz, Kordeckiego Street, Kosančićev Venac, Krakowska Street, Bydgoszcz, Krasilnikov Mansion, Królowej Jadwigi Street, Bydgoszcz, Kwiatowa Street (Bydgoszcz), Kypseli, Athens, La Buena Dicha, La Gran Peña, La Rambla Building, La Ribera Hotel, Lars J. Fiksdal House, Las Gdański water supply station, Bydgoszcz, Las Tiendas Building, Legnica, León Cathedral, Nicaragua, Lester A. Cramer, Levin House (Tel Aviv), Liepāja, Lloyd Palace, Louis Wenger, Ludwig Buchholz's Tannery, Bydgoszcz, Lugoj, Lutheran church (Ganja), Luxburg-Carolath Cemetery, Lyman Terrace, Main Building (University of Notre Dame), Main building of Bydgoszcz Music Academy, Maksymiliana Piotrowskiego Street in Bydgoszcz, Mansion of the Marquis of Riestra, Marcinkowskiego Street, Bydgoszcz, Marin Museum of Contemporary Art, Marshal Ferdinand Foch Street, Bydgoszcz, Martyn Brothers House, Masalitina House, Mashiach Borochoff House, Masjid Hajjah Fatimah, Masjid Jamae, Maxwell House (Stedman, North Carolina), McGrath Cafe and Hotel, Mechanical School No. 1, Bydgoszcz, Mechanical School No. 1, Bydgoszcz, Melkonov-Yezekov House, Mendoza Mansion, Mežaparks, Michler's Palace, Mikhail Ikonnikov, Mikołaja Reja Street, Bydgoszcz, Milan Antonović, Ministry of Agriculture (Argentina), Molenbeek-Saint-Jean, Monofora, Monument to Ramos de Azevedo, Monumental Cemetery of Mortara, Moscoso Park, Mrs. C. Morse Ely House, Mühle House, Municipal Market of Feira de Santana, Municipal Public Archive of Feira de Santana, Municipal Theatre, Bydgoszcz, Museu do Ipiranga, Museum of the Military Police of the state of São Paulo, Nahalat Binyamin, Nakielska Street, Bydgoszcz, National Philharmonic in Warsaw, Neoclassical architecture in Belgium, Neomodern, Nevsky Prospect, New Market Square, Bydgoszcz, New Town Hall (Hanover), New York Academy of Medicine, North Caucasus Railway Administration Building, North Philadelphia station, North Presbyterian Church (Cleveland, Ohio), Obrońców Bydgoszczy Street, Bydgoszcz, Oculus (architecture), Olana State Historic Site, Old Dairy Farm Depot, Old Market square, Bydgoszcz, Old Tao Nan School, Old Tower (Mariupol), Old Town Hall of Timișoara, Ortaköy Mosque, Oskar Ewald Tenement, Ossoliński Alley, Bydgoszcz, Ottoman architecture, Ottoman Empire, Our Lady of Mercy Church (Buenos Aires), Palace of Justice of the Argentine Nation, Palace of Pizarro, Quito, Palaces and park ensemble in Ostromecko, Palacio de la Diputación de Pontevedra, Palacio de Ripalda, Palacio del Marqués de Palomares, Palácio Monroe, Palais de Justice, Brussels, Palais de la Cité, Palazzo del Credito Italiano, Palazzo del Touring Club Italiano, Palazzo delle Assicurazioni Generali (Milan), Palazzo Meroni, Palazzo Mincuzzi, Palsmane Manor, Panevėžys Cathedral, Pantheon of the Duchess of Sevillano, Paris during the Second Empire, Parroquia Nuestra Señora de la Piedad (Temperley), Passage du Nord, Paul Hankar, Paul Storz Tenement, Paul Whitman, Persian column, Peryn, Petrov Mansion, Phát Diệm Cathedral, Phi Mu Sorority House (Urbana, Illinois), Piarist High School (Timișoara), Piastowski Square, Bydgoszcz, Piazza De Ferrari, Piotra Skargi Street, Bydgoszcz, Place de Brouckère, Place de la Bourse, Brussels, Place de la Monnaie, Place du Jeu de Balle, Plaza de San José, Podwale Street, Bydgoszcz, Pomorska Street, Bydgoszcz, Pontevedra City Hall, Pontevedra Normal School Building, Popov Mansion, Presbyterian Church at Bound Brook, Presque Isle County Courthouse, Profitable house of I. M. Trofimenko, Propeller Island City Lodge, Prospect Park South, Przyrzecze Street, Bydgoszcz, Quadrifora, Quietdale, Quinta de Olivos, Ralph Gerganoff, Ramos de Azevedo, Reardon Building, Reinhold Zschiesche Tenement, Reinhold Zschiesche Tenement, Residential House of Police Officers, Resursa Obywatelska Palace, Revivalism (architecture), Richard H. Mitchell House, Richard L. Cawood Residence, Rimini, Romanian architecture, Romanian Revival architecture, Rong Zhai, Rudolf Heinrich Zirkwitz, Russian neoclassical revival, Russian Revival architecture, Ryndzyun hydropathic, S. C. Mayer House, Saint Catherine's Church, Brussels, Saint Joseph's Church, Brussels, Saint Mary's Royal Church, Saint Mary's Royal Church, Saint Sophia Cathedral, Zhytomyr, Saint-Ambroise, Paris, Saint-Augustin, Paris, San Carlos Cathedral (Negros Occidental), San Francisco Ferry Building, San Miguel de Tucumán, Santa Bárbara Military Cathedral, Santa Barbara, Turin, São José Church, Sarasota Times Building, Sarnowa, Rawicz, Schaerbeek, Scott County Courthouse (Illinois), Second Empire style, Seminaryjna Street, Sielanka Estate, Bydgoszcz, Simon Kldiashvili, Słowackiego Street, Bydgoszcz, Sorsogon Cathedral, Southern Vermont College, Southmoor Apartment Hotel, Spanish architecture, Spanish Colonial Revival architecture, edit) Spanish Eclectic, Square de l'Aviation, St. Ann Cathedral, Ponta Grossa, St. Charles Borromeo Cathedral, São Carlos, St. James the Apostle Cathedral, Santiago de los Caballeros, St. James the Apostle Cathedral, Santiago de los Caballeros, St. Jerome's Cathedral (Saint-Jérôme), St. Joseph's Cathedral, Fortaleza, St. Nicholas Cathedral (Almaty), Stalinist architecture, Stanisław Rolbieski Tenement, Staszica and Paderewskiego Streets, Bydgoszcz, Status Quo Ante Synagogue (Târgu Mureș), Stile Umbertino, Świętego Floriana Street, Swiętej Trojcy Street, Bydgoszcz, Świętojańska Street, Bydgoszcz, Syberg, T. Ben Loetscher House, Tagbilaran Cathedral, Tai Wan Tau, Tayabas Basilica, Teatro São Pedro (São Paulo), Tel Aviv, Temple of Saint Anthony of Padua, Theatre Square, Bydgoszcz, Theonia Reichhardt House, Theonia Reichhardt House, Thomas Frankowski Tenement, Thomas I. Stoner House, Timișoara Palace of Culture, Timișoara, Tiradentes Palace, Toledo and Ohio Central Railroad Station, Toruńska Street, Bydgoszcz, Totalitarian architecture, Town Hall of Feira de Santana, Town Hall of Porto Alegre, Trajan Square, Timișoara, Trifora, Turin, Turkish Military Cemetery, University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, Urdaneta Cathedral, Ushkova House, Valle-Inclán High School, Viçosa, Minas Gerais, Victor Emmanuel II Monument, Víctor Eusa Razquin, Victorian architecture, Victorian decorative arts, Villa Bianca (Thessaloniki), Villa Crespi (Orta San Giulio), Villa del Sole, Villa Fritz Heroldt, Villa Heinrich Dietz, Villa La Gaeta, Villa Madre Cabrini, Villa Maria (Long Island), Villa Pessina, Villa Pilar, War College Building, Bydgoszcz, War College Building, Bydgoszcz, Water Palace, Weiss Palace, Wilhelm Bockslaff, William G. Smith House (Davenport, Iowa), Window, Władysław Ekielski, Wolcott House (Mission Hills, Kansas), Wool Market Square, Bydgoszcz, Yehuda Magidovitch, Ziemiełowice Palace, Zverin Monastery, Zygmunt Krasiński Street, Bydgoszcz